My name is Emily and I am the new Materials Management Coordinator for the City of Flagstaff. This means I am the new coordinator for the Master Recycler program! As I step into this role, I am learning so much about what you all do and what the City does to increase public knowledge and participation in recycling. I am so excited to jump in and start doing the work with you all! But before we get started, I wanted to take a moment to introduce myself and share what I experienced during my first week on the job.
The Rethink Waste Plan was adopted by City Council in October 2017 to guide future efforts related to recycling and materials management. The plan included the following three-phases to implement the plan’s vision:
Phase 1: Years 1-3
· Institutionalize a materials management framework for decision making that emphasizes actions that reduce impacts across the life-cycle of materials
· Implement foundational programs and policies
· Establish accurate baseline metrics
Phase 2: Years 4-5
· Reevaluate goals
· Develop a long-term strategic plan with policies and initiatives that help Flagstaff achieve waste prevention and diversion goals.
Phase 3: Years 6 and beyond
· Implement the policies and initiatives outlined in the strategic plan.
We are currently entering the final year of Phase 1 and have had success in implementing key initiatives outlined in the plan.
One of the biggest areas of opportunity for increasing waste diversion exists at multifamily complexes where many lack recycling infrastructure. Last year, the City adopted a new policy that requires all new commercial and multifamily development to create a Materials Management Plan that includes how they plan to deal with waste and recyclables on the property. This policy has helped the City ensure the future developments allocate adequate space for recycling infrastructure and encourage property managers to adopt best-practices.
With an increase in Solid Waste fees this year, the City secured permanent funding for recycling outreach programming and staff. This will allow the City to expand the reach of education and outreach efforts to decrease contamination and increase recycling rates.
The City also secured funding needed to implement Volumetric Pricing, which will create additional smaller trash cart size options for residents for a lower price. This program model, which creates an economic incentive to decrease waste and increase recycling, is a fundamental piece of successful recycling programs across the country.
It also continues to get easier to recycle in public spaces. In 2018, the City installed recycling bins throughout downtown near Heritage Square and Wheeler Park, as well as high-traffic areas in City parks.
City staff have also been collaborating with local builders to pilot some construction and demolition waste diversion efforts. As one example, the demolition of the existing building to make way for the new Municipal Courthouse will see all the clean concrete diverted through use as alternative daily cover at the landfill.
Data and Metrics
A focus of this first phase of the Rethink Waste Plan is reviewing how the City manages its waste and recycling data. Recently we’ve updated how the City’s diversion rate is calculated, which you can see below. If seen previous diversion rates, you may notice that these new rates are lower. This is due the fact that we are now properly accounting for the non-recyclable material that residents are placing in their recycling bins, but ultimately sorted out and delivered to the landfill as trash.
There is still work to be done calculating more accurate metrics. For example, the City does not have access to the waste and recycling data from private haulers that collect from some commercial and multifamily properties. Without this data, the City cannot calculate an accurate waste generation per capita figure, which is what we will use as a baseline to evaluate future efforts.
In order to solve this lack of private hauler data, we are looking into potential regulations on private haulers that operate within Flagstaff. Many cities in Arizona and nationally, require private haulers to report the tons of material they collect, as well as ensure that they have the proper insurance and provide their clients with the appropriate recycling information. Staff will be proposing recommendations to City Council this fall.
Additionally, we plan to rollout a pilot version of Volumetric Pricing sometime in the next year, as well as start doing community-wide outreach to introduce the program to Flagstaff residents. Ultimately the City plans to rollout the program to all of Flagstaff in 2020-21. When that time comes, we hope that Master Recyclers will help spread the word and increase participation.
If you have any questions about the work that we have been doing and plan to do in the future, please contact Dylan at firstname.lastname@example.org.
The growing problem of plastic waste is nothing new. We’ve all heard stories of the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, and even seen with our own eyes the endless stream of plastic bags flying by on a windy day. But the stories are increasing in frequency, and the scientific studies quantifying the volumes of waste are getting better constrained. Public awareness of the problem is growing. The big question is “What do we do about it?”
Effective solutions to a global problem can seem like an impossible goal. But you have to start somewhere if you want to effect change. Citizens, communities, non-profits, corporations, and governments alike are working towards the common goal of reducing the problem of plastic waste. Local groups, such as Master Recyclers help with community efforts to reduce plastic waste, while non-profits and corporations sponsor large scale efforts such as the Ocean Cleanup plastic boom deployed to the North Pacific gyre. Governments can enact taxes such as Washington D.C.’s 5 cent per bag fee, or outright bans on plastic bags such as in Austin, TX and Seattle, WA. The Government of Kenya banned all plastic bags in 2017 with the penalty for violation being 4 years in prison!
Identifying the problem of plastic waste isn’t difficult, NPR has dedicated an entire series to the subject. You can find many engaging articles at: https://www.npr.org/series/684530164/the-plastic-tide. One of those articles highlights an individual who is having a large-scale effect on the problem in the Philippines. His name is Froilan Grate and he is a native Filipino who became disheartened when he moved to Manila for college from his rural home and was confronted first hand with the overwhelming volume of plastic waste that pervades Manila Bay. He set out to do something about it, first by changing his individual habits to eliminate plastic waste, and then expanding those efforts to involve entire communities to take action. With the support of non-profits like GAIA, he organized community clean-ups that included something new, brand audits. Now, when community volunteers perform clean-ups, they categorize and quantify the waste by type and brand and then publish their results. While this sort of public shaming doesn’t typically work to change individual behaviors, it eventually garnered the attention of the multi-national corporations whose bottom line depends on their brand names. This led to Froilan being invited to Washington D.C. to participate in a round-table discussion on the global problem of plastic waste with some of the very companies he was shaming with his brand audits. You can read more of his inspiring story at: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2019/01/15/683734379/an-island-crusader-takes-on-the-big-brands-behind-plastic-waste
Another effort you may have heard about is The Ocean Cleanup’s ambitious goal of cleaning up the North Pacific Gyre using a 2000 ft long boom to collect floating plastic debris. The Ocean Cleanup is a non-governmental organization founded by Dutch inventor Boyan Slat which has received enormous funding from national governments, the U.N., and private corporations. One reason the project has received so much support is that it can deliver easily understandable results. By measuring firsthand the amount of waste being removed from the ocean, it’s easy to see the effect of the project. The boom was launched last September from San Francisco and after being deployed, has captured 2 metric tons of plastic waste. Unfortunately, the real world and the ocean in particular is a tough environment for any new design to perform in, and after 2 and a half months in service the boom was damaged to the point that it needed to be removed for repairs. It’s currently in Hawaii undergoing repairs and modifications to help it perform better. You can read more about the project at: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/04/a-grand-plan-to-clean-the-great-pacific-garbage-patch
Businesses and corporations have a unique and very powerful way to change how we all use plastic products. By adopting a materials management approach to their products, and committing to responsibly produce AND dispose of their products, businesses can provide a model for others to follow which proves that sustainability and profits are not mutually exclusive. One example of this is COSTA Sunglasses, who have recently launched a line of sunglasses whose frames are made from discarded plastic fishing nets. They didn’t stop there though, the glass, aluminum, and even the foam nose pads are made from recycled materials and designed to be recovered and recycled again at the end of their useful lifespan. Simply return your old glasses and they will disassemble them and recycle the individual components. By partnering with suppliers who sell recycled materials, they are helping markets grow. From the fishermen who are incentivized to recover and sell their damaged nets, to consumers who purchase the products, the materials loop is closing and keeping discards out of the landfill and the environment. COSTA was recently awarded a Sustainability Award from REI for their innovative products. You can read more at: https://www.rei.com/blog/news/costa-makes-100-percent-recyclable-sunglasses
Governments have the ability to have the largest effect on the problem of plastic waste through legislation and regulation. Unfortunately, many governments (from local to national) don’t have the will and/or funding to adequately tackle the problem. Some governments are actually prevented from addressing the problem through preemption laws such as we have in Arizona. In 2015 the Arizona Legislature passed a law stating that local governments cannot regulate the sale and use of plastic bags. This has had a particular affect here in Flagstaff, where the local community wants to regulate plastic bags but we don’t have the ability to do so. At present, we can only compel businesses to engage in voluntary efforts to reduce plastic bags. One local government, the City of Baltimore, has partnered with a non-profit organization, the Waterfront Partnership to launch a low-cost solution to the problem of litter and debris flowing into Chesapeake Bay from the area’s tributary rivers. The Trash Wheel Project utilizes the river’s current to turn a water wheel, which in turn propels a conveyor belt that gathers all the floating debris the river is carrying before it empties into the Bay. A solar panel array powers the wheel when the current isn’t strong enough. The local community has embraced the project, and it has expanded to 3 locations which have adopted lives of their own. Dubbed Mr. Trash Wheel, Professor Trash Wheel, and Captain Trash Wheel, they have developed loyal followings and even have their own Twitter feeds! Despite being low-technology solutions, they are actually quite effective and extremely cost-efficient. Since their deployment in 2014, the Trash Wheels have collected over 750,000 plastic bottles, 900,000 styrofoam containers, and 500,000 grocery bags. All of those materials were bound for the ocean, but are instead diverted to waste-to-energy power plants that provide electricity to the area. This is a great example of local action having a significant effect on a global problem. You can learn more about Mr. Trash Wheel here: https://www.baltimorewaterfront.com/healthy-harbor/water-wheel/
The problem of plastic waste is a global one that affects all living things. But solutions to this problem exist at all scales, from the individual who reduces their use of single-use plastics, to multi-national corporations who innovate alternative materials and processes. Master Recyclers can play an integral role in helping convey information and solutions to their communities.
NAU Researchers leading the PLACE4FEWS Project are seeking citizen volunteers who would like to contribute to cutting-edge research in food, energy and water systems, community sustainability and emergency management of supplies.
The project is a partnership between the Center for Science Teaching and Learning and the School of Informatics, Computing, and Cyber Systems (SICCS) as a supplement to the FEWSION project, led by SICCS professor Benjamin Ruddell. The National Science Foundation provided NAU with a $463,000 grant to recruit citizen scientists to actively map and study local community food, energy, and water systems (FEWS) for the Flagstaff area.
PLACE4FEWS is designed to engage citizens in learning about, mapping, and engaging others in understanding the source-to-consumer pipeline of Food, Energy, and Water. This pipeline is critical—more critical than most people realize until it’s disrupted by natural disasters, winter weather or scarcity. Knowing where important resources like food, water and energy come from and how they get here will help plan for those disruptions.
In 2018, a first cohort of citizen volunteers and NAU students provided critical insight into the content and data collection methods while initiating conversations and contacts with representatives of the food, energy, and water sectors of the Flagstaff area. This led to the refinement of a process titled FEWSION for Community Resilience (F4R).
According to local F4R coordinator Sean Ryan, “Cohort 1 really helped us to slim down and refine the process and the content that may be most meaningful for communities like Flagstaff when engaging in a citizen driven process to map FEW Systems. By engaging in this project citizens will have the opportunity to map and learn about their personal FEWS, Flagstaff Community FEWS, and in what ways the community depends upon, or is linked to critical FEWS resources across the nation.”
All residents 18 years of age and older can participate in this unique project by helping provide answers to commonly asked questions: “Where does my food come from?” “How could we best restore resources in the case of an emergency?” or “What are sustainable choices we could make as a community?”
No special skills are required. Flagstaff area residents who work in the food, energy and water system fields are welcome to apply (i.e. grocers, utility operators, drivers, emergency responders), as are elected and unelected public officials and staff, college students, and citizens with an interest in food, energy, water, and improving community resilience.
Participants will spend about 80 hours over the course of the next 6 months in training workshops and follow-up meetings, collecting data, providing project feedback, and interviewing and engaging community members.
To apply, or for questions about volunteering with PLACE4FEWS, please contact Sean Ryan at Sean.Ryan@nau.edu / (928) 523-0990. The deadline to apply is January 30th. A welcome and orientation session will be held on the evening of January 30th.
Remember to forget the numbers and recycle your plastics by shape! In Flagstaff, the only plastics you can recycle are bottles jugs and jars.
As always, you can find out a complete list of what is recyclable at www.recyclebycity.com/flagstaff.
As you are all aware, plastics recycling has changed dramatically in Flagstaff due to China’s National Sword policy banning imports of our heavily contaminated recyclable materials. As a result, only plastic bottles, jugs, and jars are accepted at the Flagstaff Materials Recovery Facility (MRF). Unfortunately, many residents are not aware of these changes and continue to put non-recyclable plastics in their carts. This practice contaminates the recycling stream and it’s necessary for the MRF staff to try and screen them out. While they do their best at that task, the large volume means that some always slip through the cracks and end up in the baler. The effects of that combination are a more expensive and resource-intensive trip to the landfill for the ones that get screened, and contaminated recycling bales that may get rejected so the whole load goes to the landfill.
We’ve created a new tag with the updated information and need your help getting them out to the public. We’re planning a cart tagging project to get these directly into the hands of Flagstaff residents. Solid Waste Collections staff have determined that the average weekly set-out rate for residential recycling carts is only around 60%, while the trash set-out rate is over 90%. Based on that fact, we intend to attach these new tags on garbage carts in select areas to get the word out. Please check the volunteer calendar if you’d like to help with this important effort.
Targeted cart inspections and tagging
We’re also in the process of designing and implementing a City-wide cart inspection and tagging protocol. City of Flagstaff GIS staff are developing a mobile app that will allow Collections Drivers, Code Inspectors, Sustainability Staff, and Master Recyclers to track addresses as they are inspected and tagged. This will be long-term project that we are hoping to begin early next year.
We’ll need lots of help as we plan to target areas for 3 inspections per month with the goal of drastically reducing contamination rates. We will plan on inspecting recycling carts and identifying non-recyclable items and alerting the resident to what items need to be kept out and disposed of in their garbage carts. Hopefully, we will see contamination rates go down and award the “Looking Good!” tags before we move on to the next area. Be on the lookout for volunteer opportunities soon. Please feel free to contact Felix at email@example.com or Dylan at firstname.lastname@example.org if you’d like more information
Holiday season is in full swing and Albert has been hard at work getting the word out on how to properly dispose of fresh-cut Christmas Trees. He was recently spotted at Allen’s Tree Sales on Butler Ave. handing out Treecycle ornaments and informing people of the curbside pick-up and community drop-off options for Treecycling. The ornaments are being distributed with fresh-cut trees sold at Allen’s Tree Sales, Warner’s Nursery, Flagstaff Farmers Market, and Home Depot. Recycle By City also has information about the dates for curbside pick-up and maps for the drop-off locations. Please help spread the word!
On November 27th, City Council will consider adopting a new solid waste rate structure that will increase the amount that residents, businesses, property managers, and waste haulers pay for solid waste disposal and recycling services.
Creating a Sustainable Solid Waste Fund
The rates for Solid Waste services have not been adjusted in over 10 years and a number of projects, goals, and initiatives make it necessary to raise rates.
First off, the Solid Waste Section is required to maintain a minimum fund balance of 10% of revenues generated. A number of federally mandated capital projects at the Cinder Lake Landfill and improvements to the collection fleet put the fund at risk of meeting this minimum fund balance.
The City also adopted the Rethink Waste Plan in 2017 and, at the moment, there is no dedicated funding for achieving the goals outlined in that plan including:
Reaching zero waste (90% diversion) by 2050
Reducing overall waste generation
Reducing the greenhouse gas emissions associated with Flagstaff’s consumption
What does the rate proposal look like?
For single-family residents, rates will increase 7.5% each year for a period of five years. The table below shows what this looks like to the solid waste portion of your utility bill:
Other Solid Waste fees, including commercial collection and landfill tipping fees, will see a one-time 3% increase.
How will increased revenues be spent?
Volumetric Pricing (Pay-As-You-Throw)
The rate increase will allow the Solid Waste Section to implement key initiatives outlined in the Rethink Waste Plan, including a volumetric pricing program, otherwise known as pay-as-you-throw. This program would establish smaller trash cart size options for single-family residents and the smaller the cart you choose, the less you pay. This would create a monetary incentive for residents to reduce their waste and recycle more. Over 9,000 other communities across the country have implemented this type of rate structure, typically resulting in a doubling in the amount of recyclables collected.
Expanded Recycling Outreach
At the moment, there is no dedicated funding for recycling outreach incorporated into the existing Solid Waste rate structure. As a result, the City spends about $0.16 per resident on recycling outreach. This compares to recycling leaders, such as Portland, San Francisco, and Austin, that spend well over $1.00 per resident. This rate proposal would allow Flagstaff to increase this amount to $0.80 per resident.
Major Capital Projects
The rate proposal would also make possible multiple capital projects at the Cinder Lake Landfill, including a landfill gas capture system, that would drastically reduce the amount of greenhouse gas emissions generated by the landfill.
Want to learn more?
Staff will be hosting an open house discussing these fees at the Cinder Lake Landfill (6670 Landfill Road, Flagstaff, AZ 86004) on November 16th, at 12:30 pm. You can also attend the Council Meeting where this item will be discussed, which is taking place on November 20th at 6 pm at City Hall.
If you have any questions about the rate proposal, you can find a detailed report on the proposal here or contact Dylan Lenzen at email@example.com or 928-213-2158.
Over the past year, City staff and community stakeholders have put in the hard work of drafting Flagstaff’s Climate Action and Adaptation Plan. The Draft Plan is nearly complete and is available to review here: Draft Climate Action and Adaptation Plan
As Master Recyclers you might be particularly interested in the section devoted to Waste and Consumption that begins on page 77. Included in that section are the City’s goals, targets, and strategies to reduce the climate impacts of Flagstaff’s material consumptions.
There are several ways to provide feedback on the Plan including 3 Open Houses at the Murdoch Community Center (203 E. Brannen Ave) from 5:30 to 7:30pm. The October 4th meeting will focus on Water and Forests, the October 8th meeting will focus on Energy, Economic Prosperity & Recreation, and the October 11th meeting will focus on Transportation & Land Use, and Waste & Consumption.
For those unable to attend an Open House, comments can be submitted via a survey here: survey.
If you have questions please feel free to contact Jenny Niemann, our Climate and Energy Specialist at: 928-213-2150 or JNiemann@FlagstaffAZ.gov
Did you know that you can actually divert your yard waste through the City's normal bulky trash collection? Last month, the City's Solid Waste department began picking up yard clippings and other green waste from resident's bulky trash piles to be diverted separately from the rest of your waste.
These yard trimmings are actually very valuable to the City in the form of "alternative daily cover" at the landfill. Alternative daily cover, otherwise known as ADC, refers to the material used to cover the surface of an active face of the landfill at the end of each day. Landfills are required to do so and instead of utilizing virgin material for this purpose, the Flagstaff's landfill uses alternatives, such as green waste generated in Flagstaff, that is bound for disposal at the landfill.
Keep it neat and separated
In order to take advantage of this new diversion opportunity, your green waste needs to be separated from other waste you place in your bulky pile. As long as it is easily separated and distinguishable from the rest of your waste, Solid Waste crews will pick this material up separately and direct it for use at the landfill for alternative daily cover.
While you're at it, make sure that you are using the bulky trash collection program properly. The program is only meant for your yard clippings, tree limbs, and any other household trash that doesn't fit in your normal trash bin. Despite this, Solid Waste crews often find hazardous waste, electronics, appliances and construction waste that doesn't belong. Disposing of these types of items in your bulky pile makes the whole process less efficient and more difficult for crews to divert green waste material.
Lastly, make sure that you know when you're bulky waste pickup is scheduled. Bulky waste should be placed on the curb no earlier than one week before your scheduled collection week. If you're unsure of when your bulky waste is scheduled for pickup, visit www.recyclebycity.com/flagstaff to sign up for collection reminders. If you have any questions about the program, feel free to contact Dylan Lenzen at firstname.lastname@example.org or 928-213-2158.
With the recent changes to plastic recycling you may be searching for more sustainable alternatives to things like plastic cups, take-out containers, straws, coffee cups, and more that are now finding their way to the landfill. Many of have pointed to compostable or biodegradable plastics as a possible solution. But are these supposedly green alternatives, a viable solution when used here in Flagstaff?
The answer to that question is a nuanced one, but ultimately at this point in time, using compostable or biodegradable plastics offers marginal benefits, if any, to their disposable alternatives. Currently there are multiple barriers preventing them from being a viable alternative to standard plastic disposables.
Where to compost?
The biggest obstacle to utilizing these compostable and biodegrable options is a lack of facilities that can compost them. Just because they are labeled compostable does not mean that they will break down in any compost pile, and certainly not your backyard pile. These products are designed to breakdown in a "controlled composting environment," which means that they need an industrial facility that reaches temperatures higher than 140 degrees. This type of facility does not exist in Northern Arizona, at least not yet. If you've ever tried to compost these types of items in your backyard compost, you might find something similar to the picture below leftover after all other material has decomposed.
Some might argue that even though these products can't be composted here in Flagstaff, they are still better than standard plastic because they will break down faster if they end up in the landfill or our environment. This also is not the case. Because these products require such a specific set of circumstances to decompose, they do not break down quickly in a landfill where there is no light, oxygen or microbes to help with decomposition. They also do not solve the problem with plastic pollution in the ocean, as oceans do not provide the appropriate temperatures needed for their decomposition either.
Even when looking at the upstream impacts of these compostable products, it is debatable whether they provide a significant upside over their oil-based alternatives. Compostable, or bio-plastics, are typically made from corn, which is produced in a resource intensive manner utilizing heavy machinery, fertilizers, and pesticides. All of these inputs require oil, making it difficult to argue that bio-plastics foster less dependence on petroleum than the standard oil-based plastics.
As you can see there are many caveats associated with these types of products, which leaves much room for confusion on the part of consumers. Depending on how compostable products are marketed or labeled, consumers may be unsure of how to actually dispose of them. Because they often are misconstrued for standard plastics, they often end up in the recycling stream where they can contaminate loads of recyclable plastic.
How to be a better consumer?
While compostable and biodegradable plastics do not provide us with a very obvious solution to our plastic problem in Flagstaff (at least not right now), there are still very clear ways to reduce the amount of plastic heading to the landfill and your environmental footprint. As we have always stressed, the best thing to do is reduce and reuse. Whether it is a reusable water bottle, coffee mug, grocery bag, or even take-out container, avoid single-use products entirely by bringing your own durable alternatives.
There are other things you can do to minimize the impacts of these products, including:
Watch for containers and bags labeled “compostable”, “biodegradable”. They will often be labeled with a #7.
Keep these containers out of your recycling bin. Mixing the these bio-plastics with standard plastics together causes problems for petroleum plastics recycling.
Keep them out of compost containers as well. They won't break down in your backyard compost pile and it is costly for the local composting operations that do exist to remove them.
Purchase locally made foods or grow your own to avoid the need for packaging for transportation and storage.
Plastics recycling in Flagstaff is changing and going forward, you will no longer be able to recycle certain types of plastics in their curbside bin. Until now, residents have been able to recycle all types of plastic, numbers 1-7, as long as they were rigid. As of June 1st, 2018, the only types of plastic that will be accepted for recycling are plastic bottles, jugs and jars.
As we've mentioned before, this decision stems from changes in the national and international recycling market. The recycling market has been significantly impacted due to the Chinese government no longer accepting certain types of recyclables as imports. Until recently, China has accepted roughly half of the world’s plastic and paper recyclables. The sudden ban on much of these materials has sent international markets for recyclables into a tailspin. Norton Environmental, the company responsible for sorting and selling Flagstaff’s recyclables, has been unable to find buyers for these types of plastic. Flagstaff is not alone, as many other communities around the country have been forced to remove items from their acceptable materials list or send significant amounts of formerly recyclable materials to the landfill.
What can consumers do?
While this recent decision by China to ban certain types of recyclables was sudden, it is the result of a long-term and growing problem of material consumption and contamination in the world’s recycling stream. Despite the fact that people are putting more recyclables in their recycling bins, they have also been increasingly placing more non-recyclable items into their bin. This is known as “wishful recycling,” which actually makes it more difficult and costly to process recyclable items. The end result is that more recyclable items get sent to the landfill as contamination.
These changes do provide an opportunity for all of us to reflect on the purpose of recycling. Recycling reduces the demand on natural resources, lowers the energy needed to create the products we use daily, and saves valuable landfill space. While it can feel good to put all of our trash in the recycling bin, doing so negates the benefits of recycling.
To realize the benefits of recycling, only the correct types of plastics can be recycled – wishful recycling must come to a halt. Going forward, sort your plastics by shape. Forget the number and chasing arrow symbol found on some plastics. Instead only recycle your plastic bottles, jugs, and jars. This includes beverage, toiletry, and soap bottles, as well as milk jugs and peanut butter jars (just make sure they are clear of any food). Any plastic packaging that does not fit these shapes is not recyclable, including items such as bags, wraps, trays, take-out containers, cups, and produce containers. Just make sure to keep recycling your cardboard, paper, and metal cans. While you’re at it, touch up on recycling basics by visiting our online recycling guide at www.recyclebycity.com/flagstaff.
The best thing that we can do is to choose durable, reusable items and avoid throwing items in either your recycling or trash bin. And, don’t forget to bring your own reusable mug, or carrying a reusable water bottle or shopping bag with you on the go. Find out what you can do to prevent waste by visiting www.flagstaff.az.gov/BYO.
If you have questions about these changes, feel free to reach out to Dylan at email@example.com or check out our webpage explaining to to sort your plastic at www.flagstaff.az.gov/plasticrecycling.
We all secretly cringe when we see items going into the trash knowing they’re going to the landfill. It seems that the number of disposable items such as single-use water bottles, coffee cups, and grocery bags is at an all-time high. With more than one million disposable coffee cups going to the landfill annually and billions of plastic and paper grocery bags being used every year, there is reasonable cause for concern. Whether the appropriate items are recycled or not, the rate of consumption of single-use items is something that impacts us all.
What are the impacts?
Single-use items impact us in many ways. They sit in the landfill creating harmful emissions. Many of these items are lined with polyethylene (a possible health hazard), which often impacts lower-income residents in the community first. Beyond this, the production impacts of these disposable items are tremendous. The amount of resources and emissions associated with the production and distribution of one plastic water bottle or plastic bag alone is significant. We also must not forget the photos or videos of wildlife we have all seen being impacted by single-use waste. Needless to say, the impact list goes on and the pile of waste keeps building.
More and more Flagstaff residents are bringing their own reusable mugs, water bottles and shopping bags when they go, but we need more to take action. To inspire more residents to bring their own, we are kicking off a B.Y.O. (Bring Your Own) campaign.
What is the B.Y.O. campaign?
The B.Y.O. campaign is our way of tackling single-use waste in the Flagstaff community. We hope to encourage more Flagstaff residents and visitors to take part in B.Y.O. behavior every day.
When will the campaign begin?
The campaign is kicking off this month. Over the next couple months, we will be tabling, posting to social media, and spreading the word at events like Earth Day, as well as at grocery stores and coffee shops around town.
Do residents in our community not care? Is the action of bringing your own too difficult? To get an idea of what motivates community members and to see why some may not participate, we surveyed the community.
What did we find?
After receiving over 55 responses in the community, we found that the greatest barrier to taking part in B.Y.O. behavior is that they simply forget or find it inconvenient to bring these items. One surprising trend we saw was that in the Flagstaff community, most people either use these items regularly (76% to 100% of the time) or hardly at all (0% to 25% of the time). We also found that of the possible actions, people bring their reusable bags most often and bring their reusable mugs the least often.
The most common motivators for those who use reusable items are monetary incentives, environmental stewardship, and how the behaviors fit their lifestyle.
By marketing incentives, establishing community partners, getting the word out, and creating excitement, we hope to encourage this least active group to realize some of these benefits.
How can you help?
First, continue to B.Y.O. yourself. Second, encourage those around you to join in. And most importantly, join our B.Y.O. campaign by volunteering to table with us around town. There are multiple volunteer opportunities listed in the Master Recycler calendar with even more on the way. We hope you can join us in spreading the simple message of bringing your own.
Changes to the global recycling market
Many of you may have seen news stories over the paste six months or so detailing China's refusal to accepts certain types of recyclables and crackdown on the amount of contamination in bales of recyclables making their way to the country. Since its inception, recycling has depended upon international markets to extend the life of the materials we use in our everyday lives. In recent years, an increasing amount of that recycling has been sent to China. That is changing.
China's National Sword Policy, which has sent markets for waste paper and plastic into a tailspin, has forced material recovery facilities (MRFs) around the country to slow down sorting lines to improve the quality of bales and even send some material to the landfill. As a result, communities are reevaluating recycling programs and the materials they accept, as well addressing key issues that have plagued the recycling industry for decades. The main issue is that many of us are not putting the right items into our recycling bin.
For years, the U.S. has been able to pass off its contamination problem to countries like China that have been willing to accept and process dirty loads of recycling. Increasing labor costs and higher environmental standards, as well as the fact that Chinese consumers are producing a greater amount of their own waste, has meant that China is less willing to accept the world's recycling.
Impacts to Flagstaff
While no changes have been announced as to what Flagstaff residents can throw in their recycling bin, these recent events have underscored the need to reflect on why we recycle to begin with.
Why do we recycle?
Recycling our discards provides many benefits when it works properly. By replacing the need for raw materials to be extracted, it reduces the demand on natural resources, lowers the energy needed to create the products we use in our everyday lives, and even avoids disposing of items in a landfill. Sometimes it even makes us feel good inside. But, when we don't recycle properly, we begin to negate these benefits.
When we recycle items that don't belong in the recycling bin, it makes it more difficult to sort out the material that has a strong market and can actually be recycled.
At the moment, Flagstaff's infrastructure is being challenged to provide high-quality bales of material for the recycling market. Part of this is due to the fact that markets for certain materials, including some types of plastic, have always been fickle. While many of the markets for individual materials are likely to improve as processing capacity grows domestically and around the world, the current uncertainty provides a great opportunity to evaluate the list of acceptable items and ensure that only materials with strong markets are being added into the recycling market.
Flagstaff will also have to make sure that future infrastructure can produce high-quality recycling bales through improved sorting technology that many communities are already utilizing.
What can Consumers do?
Make sure to check the list of acceptable items. No changes have been made to the list yet, but we always encourage you to check back regularly, as markets can change and items can be added or removed. If you're unsure about an item, it's best to throw it in the trash (or better yet, give us a call at 928-213-2158).
Reduce and reuse. Fix and repair.
In light of these challenges, a great way to reduce the impact of our materials consumption is to simply consume less. In fact, by reducing the amount of stuff we purchase and choosing to reuse we can actually achieve greater environmental outcomes than by making sure that what we consume is recycled.
Master Recyclers will play an important role as Flagstaff deals with these challenges. Please continue to check back for news on potential changes to local recycling system and help us spread the message to the rest of Flagstaff.
These changes present an opportunity
While local infrastructure and planning will be challenged in the near term, this recent uncertainty provides a great opportunity to reflect on why we recycle and how to do it properly. It also allows us to communicate the importance of reducing and reusing, as well as develop a long-term plan for improving local processing systems to ensure that what we throw in our recycling bins can be recycled in the future.
The following is a guest post from Master Recycler, Amanda Kapp, that was originally published on Green NAU's blog.
Why are trays and trash cans absent in the NAU dining halls?
And what is this stunning machine pictured below? Both are indicators of how Dining Services is making leaps and bounds when it comes to sustainability.
How much do we waste?
Meal production, from planning to cleanup, can have big impacts on the environment. Estimates put food waste in America at 30-40%. That means ordering a pizza and immediately throwing away two delicious cheesy hot slices. Painful, no?
And there’s a resource-rich history behind each of those pizza slices. Energy, water, animal feed, fertilizer, pesticides, transportation – these are all parts of food production. By reducing food waste, we conserve those resources. In addition, wasted food decomposes in landfills releasing methane, a powerful heat-trapping gas that contributes to global warming.
NAU Dining Services employs several sustainable practices to help reduce food waste on campus and promote sustainability.
Where does NAU source its produce?
During the past academic year, Dining Services sourced 31% of its produce from Arizona farms reducing transportation miles and fuel.
Reducing food waste during meal prep
Dining Services utilizes a tracking program called LeanPath which helps kitchen staff reduce food waste during food prep – for example: using vegetable trimmings for soup stock or using leftover ingredients in other recipes. In its first year, staff reduced food waste by 20% during meal prep.
Feed people, not landfills
Through the Food Recovery Network student volunteers work with kitchen staff at the Hot Spot, Einstein’s, Starbucks and catering to package food that was not prepared but not served during the lunch hour. They transport trays to local food kitchens. During the past academic year, almost 9500 lbs. of food were donated to local food kitchens who in turn served it to Flagstaff’s most needy.
Both campus dining halls embrace trayless dining. This allows students to eat their fill but avoids the tendency to fill a tray with more food than can be consumed resulting in food waste.
How NAU campus compost is a win-win:
If you have eaten at either dining hall recently, you may have noticed there are no trashcans. This is because every food scrap that is not consumed is pulped, ground, dehydrated and turned into compost thanks to the two recently installed SOMAT machines.
After resting for a few months on south campus, this nutrient-dense compost is ready for use both in campus landscaping and at local elementary schools. With the second SOMAT machine installed, NAU hopes to divert 200,000 lbs. of food waste from the landfill over next year and turn it into sweet, sweet compost.
A big round of applause to NAU Dining Services for their work towards making NAU sustainable. Check out Campus Dining’s website to learn about other programs they offer that contribute to both healthy people and a healthy planet.
The downtown Flagstaff Library will no longer be accepting batteries, CDs, MP3 players, and cell phones. This decision was a result of safety concerns, as well as the fact that the personnel resources needed to service the bin competed with more effective collection events like Drop-off Day. Despite the elimination of this drop-off bin, the proper disposal of hazardous waste is still as convenient as ever.
The City's Drop-off Day collection events take place every April and October, where residents can safely dispose of batteries, cell phones, CDs, latex paint, CFL light bulbs, sensitive documents, and all types of electronic waste. Flagstaff residents can also dispose of hazardous waste at the Hazardous Products Center (HPC), located at the Cinder Lake Landfill. The HPC is open 8 am to 3 pm, Monday through Saturday, where all types of household hazardous waste are accepted. For information on what items the HPC accepts, please visit www.flagstaff.az.gov/hpc.
The most popular item disposed of at the library was household batteries. While it is best to recycle household batteries by taking them to a collection event or the HPC, alkaline batteries are no longer manufactured with mercury and can actually be disposed of in your household trash. That is not the case with nickel cadmium, mercury-oxide, and silver-oxide button batteries, which still contain toxic heavy metals that pollute air and water.
The best option when considering batteries may be to switch to the rechargeable variety, which can be recharged up to 1,000 times, saving resources and reducing the number of single-use batteries ending up in the landfill.
Many commercial businesses located in town accept rechargeable batteries for recycling, as well as other forms of electronic waste. To find lists and maps of participating businesses and drop-off locations, visit Flagstaff’s recycling guide at www.recyclebycity.com/flagstaff/.
If you have any questions about these changes and how you can properly dispose of your waste, please contact Dylan Lenzen at 928-213-2158 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Earlier this year, the Flagstaff City Council set a goal to take meaningful climate action. In response, the City is asking community members, local businesses, and partner institutions to help create Flagstaff's first Climate Action and Adaptation Plan.
What will this plan do?
The Climate Plan will help the Flagstaff community to identify priorities and funding mechanisms for both mitigation and adaptation action. Mitigation means reducing our contribution to climate change by reducing Flagstaff’s greenhouse gas emissions and includes actions, such as installing solar panels to increase Flagstaff’s renewable energy sources or helping homeowners install energy efficient appliances that reduce our community energy demand.
Climate adaptation means preparing for changing climate conditions by improving a community's preparedness, as well as reducing a community's vulnerability to extreme events. Examples include improving natural disaster response measures and helping individuals with asthma prepare for poor air quality days caused by wildfires. Flagstaff’s plan is called a Climate Action and Adaptation Plan to highlight our focus on both preparedness and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
What does this have to do with waste?
A lot, actually! Consumption and disposal of goods has a big impact on our climate:
- 42% of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions result from the provision of goods and food produced within the United States (EPA). The creation, distribution, consumption and disposal of goods and food we rely on daily all requires energy, but we have opportunities to reduce our impact in every state of the life cycle. Learn more from the EPA here.
- 13% of greenhouse gas emissions are from the provision of food – which we waste up to 40% of!
- 1% to 5% of greenhouse gas emissions come from waste management. Check out Flagstaff’s greenhouse gas emissions tracking and how the landfill contributes here.
The Climate Plan presents an excellent opportunity to solve waste challenges. Since consumption and waste contribute so significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, improvements in recycling and programs that reduce waste should be included as viable mitigation actions in the Flagstaff Climate Plan.
Why get involved?
The climate planning process will help us determine which measures are the most effective and appropriate for the Flagstaff community. Over the next 10 months, we’ll work with community members to understand priorities for action and concerns about vulnerabilities, as well as draft a report based on what we hear. A couple reasons to get involved in the planning process:
- The plan helps build a more resilient, responsive, and sustainable Flagstaff for its residents, businesses, and visitors.
- The City has limited resources and many competing demands. This is your opportunity to tell us your priorities and concerns when it comes to sustainable practices and policies related to climate change.
- This plan will lead directly to projects and money spent on the ground. By participating, you have an influence on public spending and project implementation.
What’s happening now?
- City staff and our partners are working to analyze climate change impacts in Northern Arizona and the potential risks to our community. We are also planning public outreach and events.
- A Steering Committee of community members has been formed to guide the planning process.
In late January, we will host our first open house to hear from the Flagstaff community. We want to know what you'd like to see in this plan, and will use this input to create a plan that fits Flagstaff's needs and priorities.
We will also hold additional events this winter and to learn more about the community's priorities and concerns related to climate action. We’ll share our first draft with the community in July. Check out the full planning timeline on the Climate Plan page.
What you can do today:
- Sign up for the Climate Plan newsletter: we’ll send you one monthly update, and notifications about public events. Sign up here.
- Get the word out: Tell your friends, neighbors, co-workers, or those you volunteer with about the upcoming planning process. Feel free to forward this email!
- Learn more:
If you’d like to chat about the climate plan, have ideas about potential climate actions, or would like to get involved, please feel free to contact Jenny Niemann, the Sustainability Section’s Climate and Energy Specialist, at JNiemann@flagstaffaz.gov or 928-213-2150.
Thank you, and we hope to work with you through this planning process.
On the October 17th, Flagstaff's City Council adopted the Rethink Waste Plan, which establishes ambitious goals and a near term plan to guide the City's efforts in reducing the impact of its waste and material consumption.
Most importantly, this plan outlines the new approach for managing Flagstaff's waste and material consumption, known as sustainable materials management. Unlike our past approach that sought to minimize the impact of waste by diverting as much as possible, materials management takes a life-cycle approach to encourage decision making that reduces the impacts that occur during the extraction, processing, transportation, and use or materials, which are often 10 to 100 times greater than the impacts of recycling or landfilling them.
Following the adoption of the plan, the goals guiding the City's future efforts include:
- Achieving "Zero Waste" by 2050 - This means we'll have to divert 90% of the waste generated within the city from the landfill by recycling, reusing, composting, diverting it through some other method.
- Reduce overall waste generation - The most effective way to reduce the impacts of our waste is to prevent it in the first place and this metric will help evaluate such efforts.
- Reduce the greenhouse gas emissions associated with Flagstaff's material consumption - Did you know that 42% of U.S. emissions are a result of the provision of materials? We hope to reduce those emissions by empowering residents to make more thoughtful consumption choices.
- Increase participation - We want everyone in Flagstaff to have access to and participate in the services the community offers. Whether that is shopping at a thrift store, attending a Fix-it Clinic, or disposing of your hazardous waste at a Drop-off Day, we want you to participate!
To help us reach these goals, the Rethink Waste Plan outlines a phased plan of action for getting us there.
Phase 1 (Years 1 - 3)
The plan mostly focuses on this first phase, during which we hope to set a foundation for future success. We hope to do this better utilizing our existing recycling infrastructure, filling in gaps in data and knowledge or the waste system in Flagstaff, and engaging residents on this new materials management vision.
Phase 2 (Years 4 - 5)
Building off the momentum of Phase 1, we plan to commission the drafting of a strategic plan with specific policy and program prescriptions to help the City get all to the goals outlined above.
Phase 3 (Years 6 and beyond)
This phase will focus on implementing the policies and programs outlined in the strategic plan that is produced as part of Phase 2.
We look forward to working with you all to carry out this plan and achieve the City's goals. If you would like to learn more about the plan and see exactly what we hope to accomplish over the next few years, we encourage you to check out the full plan.
If you have any question, contact Dylan Lenzen at 928-213-2158 or email@example.com.
The City of Flagstaff is launching a Waste to Profit program, designed to turn troublesome waste streams to profit through a partnership with the City’s Community Investment and the Sustainability Sections. The program will provide up to $8,000 in incentives to convert an idea and a waste stream into a product or service.
The first step in this process is to identify existing waste streams. To do so, the City is asking businesses and organizations to self-identify the troublesome parts of their waste stream that are not already being diverted. Examples might include vinyl signs, spent grain, non-recyclable plastics, wooden pallets or any other by-product you are producing in large quantities.
In order to participate, the City of Flagstaff will need information on the waste for diversion, including:
- Material name
- Type of material (e.g. hard plastic, organic material, packaging, construction /demolition waste, textiles, etc.)
- Rough quantity of material
- Frequency of production (is this a one-time waste product or regularly produced)
- A photo of the material
Once the City has a list of divertible materials, it will issue a “Call for Innovators” inviting entrepreneurs and businesses to submit proposals to convert the materials into a product or service. The most interesting idea will receive $4,000 in initial seed funding to help turn it into a product or service, as well as $4,000 upon the success of the product or service.
For businesses looking to divert troublesome parts of their waste stream, please contact Dylan Lenzen (firstname.lastname@example.org or 928-213-2158). Interested innovators should look for a “Call for Innovators” that will be released in early November at www.flagstaff.az.gov/wastetoprofit.
Ever wonder if something can go in your recycling bin? Check out this video made by one of our wonderful Master Recyclers, Amanda Kapp, and learn about a new website available to help you better understand what you can and can't recycle.
Take a look here: https://www.recyclebycity.com